(Kardur, DoomscourgeKardur, Doomscourge | Art by Helge C. Balzer)

Hey friends! It’s time for another precon upgrade guide, courtesy of the Scrap Trawlers. I’m Andy, and today I’ll be showing you how to give a little more pizazz to the Chaos Incarnate Starter Deck. We’ll look at how I added more goad effects, sped the deck up a bit, and increased the pain for our opponents. Let’s perfect the chaos.

Here’s the original decklist:

Disrupt Decorum

Our commander is Kardur, DoomscourgeKardur, Doomscourge, a demon berserker with a quasi-goad effect when he enters who also drains life from our opponents when attacking creatures die. With Kardur at the helm, we’d expect the deck to be full of ways to force our opponents to attack each other. Sadly, the original list only included a Geode RagerGeode Rager. So we’re upping our goad game, starting with Shiny ImpetusShiny Impetus and Parasitic ImpetusParasitic Impetus. A great way to keep a huge threat off our backs, and super cheap to pick up. And considering how much Wizards loves to drop the Impetus cycle into precons where they don’t fit thematically, you’d think they’d be no-brainers in this deck where they’re perfect. It’s like someone missed a memo here. 

Of course, we’ve gotta throw in the granddaddy of all goad spells, Disrupt DecorumDisrupt Decorum. Man, I remember when this card was around $10, and now, thanks to a few reprints, you can pick it up for under $.50. We’re also adding Vengeful AncestorVengeful Ancestor for some extra pain and Karazikar, the Eye TyrantKarazikar, the Eye Tyrant for some card draw. Bloodthirsty BladeBloodthirsty Blade is here as a more versatile (i.e. moveable) Impetus. And a goad coup de grace, straight outta Baldur’s Gate; it’s Spectacular ShowdownSpectacular Showdown. 

Don’t Come Around Here No More

The original list included a few ways to deter incoming attacks, with cards like Brash TaunterBrash Taunter and Kazuul, Tyrant of the CliffsKazuul, Tyrant of the Cliffs. But I wanted to lean into that a bit more, and make doubly sure attacks are going elsewhere. So we’re throwing in Revenge of RavensRevenge of Ravens and Blood ReckoningBlood Reckoning for a “stop hitting yourself” effect. And while we’re at it, maybe we should make it hurt more when opponents attack each other as well. For that, I’ve added Calculating LichCalculating Lich and a new card from The Brothers’ War, Blast-Furnace HellkiteBlast-Furnace Hellkite. 

Just a few more additions. To speed things up a bit, I added a Fellwar StoneFellwar Stone for just a little more ramp. I also wanted to have a way to have Kardur keep entering the battlefield. There’s a way to do it that’s a bit more expensive, which we’ll get to in a minute, and there’s the more budget-friendly way, which is Mirage PhalanxMirage Phalanx. Just bond the Phalanx to Kardur, and you’ll get a new Kardur effect every turn. 

Last, we need to have a little more insurance against the “goad problem.” And by that I mean the fact that goad becomes really bad after two players have been knocked out. When you’re the only player to attack, your final opponent will have no choice but to come at you. So to give us a little breathing room I’ve added Sudden SpoilingSudden Spoiling. While it’s only a one-time effect, hopefully it’ll give you just enough space to sneak in and deal the final blow.

Get Gone

Now it’s time for cuts! Even with a high average MV, 40 lands is just a bit much. So we’re showing Stensia BloodhallStensia Bloodhall the door, and replacing it with Fellwar StoneFellwar Stone. Bloodhall has no business being in a multiplayer deck. Do you really wanna pay 5 mana (6 if you count the Bloodhall itself) to deal 2 damage to one player when you’ve gotta deal 120 to win the game? No, you do not.

I made a few cuts simply based on mana cost, including Sepulchral PrimordialSepulchral Primordial, Explosion of RichesExplosion of Riches, Magmatic ForceMagmatic Force, Deadly TempestDeadly Tempest, Sunbird’s InvocationSunbird’s Invocation, and Scythe SpecterScythe Specter. All decent cards, but they needed to go to either lower the curve or make way for better high-cost cards, like Blast-Furnace HellkiteBlast-Furnace Hellkite.

Sepulchral PrimordialSepulchral Primordial was part of a recursion package that just didn’t fit with the theme of the deck, and I cut Profane CommandProfane Command for the same reason. The instants/sorceries theme cards are all getting binned, since it’s not what the deck is doing. So out goes GuttersnipeGuttersnipe, Thermo-AlchemistThermo-Alchemist, and Wildfire DevilsWildfire Devils.

We’re not making enough creatures to really benefit from Titan HunterTitan Hunter, so it’s gone. Joining it are SangromancerSangromancer and Hate MirageHate Mirage, because I just couldn’t find a reason to keep them.

We Spared No Expense

Okay, some of you have deep pockets and wanna fill this starter deck with all kinds of expensive replacements, so here’s a few recommendations.

Conjurer’s ClosetConjurer’s Closet is Kardur’s best friend. It’s also, unfortunately, around $7 to buy. But definitely worth it if you can afford it. Along those same lines, we’ll add Command BeaconCommand Beacon. The land is here to save the day if Kardur is in the zone and has too much tax on him.

Cunning RhetoricCunning Rhetoric is a great attack deterrent that provides card advantage. Black Market ConnectionsBlack Market Connections and Jeska’s WillJeska’s Will can both speed up your game considerably. And Blood for the Blood God!Blood for the Blood God! will give you a fresh hand and some fresh torment for your opponents. 

And, if it makes you happy, you can go crazy with tutors like: Demonic TutorDemonic Tutor, Grim TutorGrim Tutor, and Vampiric TutorVampiric Tutor.

Final Thoughts

Here’s the updated decklist:

We upgraded 14 cards for under $10, and lowered the average mana value from 4.00 to 3.84. Not a huge dent, but it’s hard to effect that without a bigger overhaul. The updated list is more thematic, synergistic, and focused. Which is exactly what we want for our precons!

That’s it for Chaos Incarnate! What’d you think of my upgrades? How do you feel about the Starter Decks? Leave a comment below with your thoughts. You can also hit us up on Twitter, or catch us making budget content on YouTube and Twitch. Stay tuned for more on the Starter Decks, and keep checking back whenever new precons are released. Until next time, remember to budget…before you buy it.

Scrap Trawlers

Scrap Trawlers is a Magic: The Gathering budget EDH streaming and video group, with gameplay, deck techs, chats, and more. Catch our videos at youtube.com/scraptrawlers. Andy, Lenny, and Bert.